Quote:
Originally Posted by SeanL
|
More like Matt Tiabbi is too dumb to write a critique of .... anything. I don't think he even realizes it is a true story. The 'critique' isn't really even of the movie, it is of war in general. Which is fine, but that doesn't make it a dumb movie, just a dumb reviewer. Most of the review is just a rehash of old (and false) arguments about the war in Iraq, not about the movie itself.
Reminds me of a few critiques I saw of Lone Survivor, talking about it being too 'over the top'....clearly completely unaware that it was a very accurate, and if anything toned down, depiction of actual events, not something someone made up. Which, like this one, just made the reviewer too dumb to critique it.