Thread: Who thinks....
View Single Post
Old 09-08-2003, 04:18 PM   #41
FilthyFinMavs
Diamond Member
 
Join Date: May 2002
Posts: 8,625
FilthyFinMavs is a jewel in the roughFilthyFinMavs is a jewel in the roughFilthyFinMavs is a jewel in the roughFilthyFinMavs is a jewel in the roughFilthyFinMavs is a jewel in the rough
Default Who thinks....

Quote:
Originally posted by: kg_veteran
Quote:
They have also had great teams to play for. A young qb is going to suck especially in a Cowboys uni. If you aren't as good as Troy Aikman or Roger Staubach you suck in this town. I understand that. We expect alot out of our qb. However, you can't expect a young qb to come right in and succeed when he has had 4 different playbooks to learn in the past 4 years.
FFM, you know better than this. I'm not saying that Carter sucks in comparison to Staubach or Aikman, although that comparison definitely magnifies his suckiness. I'm saying Carter objectively sucks; that is, he sucks in comparison to your average, run of the mill, NFL starter.

I don't care if you gave the guy one playbook for the rest of his life and assembled a ton of offensive talent around him. He will still suck.

At this point, it's not even about succeeding. No one expects Carter to win games. They just ask him not to lose games. And he can't do that.


Okay you win lol. I don't think Carter lost yesterday's game but thats a another subject for another time. Its hard for me to debate about Quincy because there is always one side who thinks he will always suck and there is my side which is he might succeed. I don't put money on him succeeding but i'm going to give him a chance. its impossible to debate Quincy here lol and thats on both sides whether you think he sucks or not.
__________________



1996-2005
FilthyFinMavs is offline   Reply With Quote