Emmitt Smith >>> Everybody Else

[Rhylan]

I'm tired of the Emmitt vs. Barry argument because Barry is a quitter, simple as that.

Talk about Emmitt versus Jim Brown, Payton, etc.. I'm all for that. But I'm sick of hearing everyone talk about Barry. Barry coulda woulda shoulda. Well, Barry hung it up when he was still awesome and hadn't won squat. So he took himself out of the running for this debate. Honor his decision by leaving him out of it.

Jim Brown quit young, too, but at least he was the all-time leading rusher at the time.

[Underdog]

Originally Posted by Rhylan

Jim Brown quit young, too, but at least he was the all-time leading rusher at the time.

Not to mention that he quit to chase some Hollywood ass - that's a noble way to leave the game...