Free Agent Watch: CP3 & D12

[41mvp]

Originally Posted by SMC0007

Not saying I disagree with your original point completely but I'll take a stab at this question.

Bosh
West, Granger
Gasol, Nash
(Pierce, garnett)?
Amare, Chandler

Bosh 17+ppg in his carrer (one time champion)
West 16,1ppg 7,2rpg
Gasol 18,4 ppg 9,2 rpg (two rings)
Nash two time MVP you wanna say more..
Pierce (one ring, 21,8 ppg, finals MVP)
Garnett(one ring ,MVP,NBA Defensive Player of the Year,19,1ppg 10.5 rpg)
Chandler(NBA champion ,NBA Defensive Player of the Year)
Amare (NBA Rookie of the Year 21,3ppg 8,6rpg)

If this guys are not superstars ,tell me who are they?

[Underdog]

Originally Posted by 41mvp

Bosh 17+ppg in his carrer (one time champion)
West 16,1ppg 7,2rpg
Gasol 18,4 ppg 9,2 rpg (two rings)
Nash two time MVP you wanna say more..
Pierce (one ring, 21,8 ppg, finals MVP)
Garnett(one ring ,MVP,NBA Defensive Player of the Year,19,1ppg 10.5 rpg)
Chandler(NBA champion ,NBA Defensive Player of the Year)
Amare (NBA Rookie of the Year 21,3ppg 8,6rpg)

If this guys are not superstars ,tell me who are they?

A superstar is a franchise player, a guy who can lead a team deep in the playoffs by themselves.

Pierce, Nash, Garnett and Amare used to be that guy, but those days are behind them... Everyone else on that list has never been, and will never be, that guy.

[DirkFTW]

Originally Posted by Underdog

A superstar is a franchise player, a guy who can lead a team deep in the playoffs by themselves.

Pierce, Nash, Garnett and Amare used to be that guy, but those days are behind them...

Like Wizards-Jordan. 6-time champion, 6-time Finals MVP, 5-time MVP, 10-time scoring champion, DPOY...

[BPo001]

Originally Posted by Underdog

A superstar is a franchise player, a guy who can lead a team deep in the playoffs by themselves.

Pierce, Nash, Garnett and Amare used to be that guy, but those days are behind them... Everyone else on that list has never been, and will never be, that guy.

My thoughts exactly.

[Kidd Karma]

Originally Posted by 41mvp

Bosh 17+ppg in his carrer (one time champion)
West 16,1ppg 7,2rpg
Gasol 18,4 ppg 9,2 rpg (two rings)
Nash two time MVP you wanna say more..
Pierce (one ring, 21,8 ppg, finals MVP)
Garnett(one ring ,MVP,NBA Defensive Player of the Year,19,1ppg 10.5 rpg)
Chandler(NBA champion ,NBA Defensive Player of the Year)
Amare (NBA Rookie of the Year 21,3ppg 8,6rpg)

If this guys are not superstars ,tell me who are they?

Broke down, once upon a time superstars.....West and Chandler I question as ever being a superstar, more like 2nd options. West was nothing without Paul. I'll give you all of those players you listed and I would think the Miami Heat would beat these guys today, on the court, not NBA Live 2004.