The Best NFL QB of 2008...?

[chumdawg]

Originally Posted by Five-ofan

no hes not. favre still turns the ball over wayyyy too much(he leads the nfl in picks) And pretty much everyone saw the jets being better. this isnt the same team as it was last year.

It's not the same team in large part because of Brett Favre. Turnovers be damned, the guy is a great QB.

[Five-ofan]

Originally Posted by chumdawg

It's not the same team in large part because of Brett Favre. Turnovers be damned, the guy is a great QB.

and i will no longer be listening to anything you have to say about football...(actually i wanna see your answer to this) turnovers be damned??? really? Just wow. You said you valued wins quite a bit which is presumably why you ranked him over warner brees and romo despite him and warner(and romo) having nearly identical records despite the fact that all 3 are CLEARLY better players. Then you just dismiss the fact that theres a bigger difference in records between favres jets and elis giants when elis numbers are closer to favres. there is NO logical argument that makes favre the best qb in the nfl right now. Literally any argument you use for favre can be applied more aptly to someone else.

[chumdawg]

Originally Posted by Five-ofan

and i will no longer be listening to anything you have to say about football...(actually i wanna see your answer to this) turnovers be damned??? really? Just wow. You said you valued wins quite a bit which is presumably why you ranked him over warner brees and romo despite him and warner(and romo) having nearly identical records despite the fact that all 3 are CLEARLY better players. Then you just dismiss the fact that theres a bigger difference in records between favres jets and elis giants when elis numbers are closer to favres. there is NO logical argument that makes favre the best qb in the nfl right now. Literally any argument you use for favre can be applied more aptly to someone else.

Don't get too excited about turnover numbers. Those are the same for any QB. Concentrate on TD's and on wins.

Give extra credit to wins.

[Five-ofan]

Originally Posted by chumdawg

Don't get too excited about turnover numbers. Those are the same for any QB. Concentrate on TD's and on wins.

Give extra credit to wins.

you got favre sneaking into the top 10 now? And i happen to think turnovers are a huge part of being a qb.