QB comparision

[Just211]

I got this off DMN and thought it was kinda interesting. I'm not totally sold on the they did this, so so will I, but these numbers are interesting



Quincy Carter

G Att Cmp Yds TD INT Rat
1. 6 17 69 0 0 48.4
2. 1 5 4 0 0 39.6
3. 7 14 130 1 1 76.5
4. 17 26 194 1 0 100.5
5. 14 33 135 0 1 41.9
6. 16 28 176 1 2 58.0
7. 15 25 241 2 0 118.9
8. 11 26 158 0 1 46.6
9. 13 30 131 0 1 42.5
10. 14 24 240 2 0 120.1
11. 21 34 201 0 1 65.9
12. 26 36 204 1 1 83.6
Totals 165 294 1883 8 8 73.3

Peyton Manning

G Att Cmp Yds TD INT Rat
1. 21 37 302 1 3 58.6
2. 21 33 188 1 3 51.1
3. 20 44 193 0 2 39.3
4. 19 32 309 1 3 63.2
5. 12 23 137 1 1 66.8
6. 20 41 235 2 2 62.6
7. 18 30 231 3 0 117.5
8. 30 52 278 2 2 69.5
9. 22 42 140 1 2 47.7
10. 26 44 276 3 2 81.3
11. 14 29 164 1 2 48.6
12. 27 42 357 3 1 105.0 Totals 223 407 2453 16 22 63.4

Donovan McNabb

G Att Cmp Yds TD INT Rat
1. 8 21 60 0 1 46.3
2. 19 36 165 1 2 51.3
3. 16 28 172 2 0 99.1
4. 19 31 157 2 1 82.3
5. 7 17 49 0 1 24.4
6. 15 32 179 3 2 69.7
7. 16 28 130 1 2 51.2
8. 19 33 214 1 0 87.2
9. 15 31 118 0 1 44.8
10. 20 32 222 2 0 103.9
11. 30 44 311 2 1 94.0
12. 17 34 186 2 2 61.6
Totals 201 367 1963 17 13 70.7

Troy Aikman

G Att Cmp Yds TD INT Rat
1. 17 35 180 0 2 40.2
2. 13 23 241 1 2 71.1
3. 6 21 83 0 2 4.0
4. 1 6 11 0 0 39.6
5. 21 40 379 2 2 81.1
6. 25 33 261 1 1 95.6
7. 7 21 54 0 3 2.8
8. 19 34 179 4 1 97.5
9. 17 30 152 1 0 81.5
10. 11 22 84 0 1 40.7
11. 18 28 125 0 4 34.7
12. 13 29 193 1 1 64.3 Totals 168 322 1942 10 19 56.5

Note: Peyton Manning's first 12 starts came in the same season. Carter, McNabb, and Aikman's first 12 starts encompassed two seasons.

Sources: Elias Sports Bureau, NFL media guides

[FINtastic]

Well there you have it, Quincy is going to be better than Peyton Manning, Donovan McNabb, and Troy "Where's my Money?" Aikman. [img]i/expressions/face-icon-small-wink.gif[/img]

[pepperfletch]

We have long way to go with Quincy and I am glad to see that he is holding his own with over first 12 game guys...actually doing better...


Lets just give the guy a chance...