2006 Heisman Talk

[Five-ofan]

Originally Posted by Just211

here's the heisman
troy smith if he beats Michigan,
Brady Quinn if Michagan beats OSU, and ND beats USC
up for graps if OSU loses to Michigan, and ND loses to USC
that would be interesting

What has brady quinn done to deserve the heisman moreso than mccoy aside from playing for ND and being older?

[Just211]

not really too much. But we all know a freahman will not win. and most people don't actaully win the heisman based on one year. You've got to be hyped up one year, just to have a shot the next. Not a perfect system, and winning doesn't always mean you're the best player. But McCoy is putting himself into position to win in the future.
Now if both OSU and ND lose McCoy has a chance, but him being a freshman, and the fact that Vince didn't even win it last year, will go against him,

[Five-ofan]

Colt is up to 4th on the ESPN heisman watch.

My personal Heisman vote at this time would look like..
Smith
Mcfadden
McCoy
Quinn
Rice

[ocelot_ark]

^^^^^ that's a smart man.

[MavsFanatik33]

Troy Smith has it unless something drastic happens against Michigan next week

[Five-ofan]

Originally Posted by MavsFanatik33

Troy Smith has it unless something drastic happens against Michigan next week

which is sad, because vince last year was alot better, think they could give it to vince for last year instead?

[MavsFanatik33]

Originally Posted by Five-ofan

which is sad, because vince last year was alot better, think they could give it to vince for last year instead?

Haha, let's see how he handles himself as a Titan the rest of the year first

[Five-ofan]

McCoy is hurt, Mcfadden is killing Tennessee.

[TheBlueVan]

it SHOULD be...
Smith
McFadden
Hart
Quinn/McCoy/Rice

I could see McCoy getting an invite, but not coming close to winning. If Quinn wins the Heisman after the total beat down received from us in the only hard game they played, i'll shoot myself. Rice might make it, it would be a nice story. plus you have to factor in geography